|
Why
Sole Proprietorships Are Accidents Waiting To Happen
Most businesses in the United States are operated
as sole proprietorships. This means
that the individual who operates the business owns the business personally. Sole proprietorships have really only one advantage….they
are very easy to get started. There
is no separate entity to set up. All
you need to do is open up a bank account under a separate tax identification
number and you are in business. If
you operate under a name other than your personal legal name, you must obtain
a fictitious name registration in most states.
Depending on the activity you are engaging in, you may need to obtain
licenses from the state or federal government.
But ease of starting the business is the ONLY benefit of a sole
proprietorship.
Sole proprietorships
provide absolutely no protection of personal assets from liabilities that
may occur in the business. If you operate your business as a sole proprietorship,
your house, your investments, your bank accounts, and all of your personal
assets are subject to attachment and are vulnerable to the liabilities that
may occur in your business.
This is because there is no separate and distinct
legal entity between your personal assets and your business assets. In a sole proprietorship all business assets
are owned individually. All liability
from the business runs to you individually.
One
example taken from an actual case illustrates the devastating results of operating
as a sole proprietorship. The names have been changed to protect the
identity of the person that this happened to.
Jim
owned a lawn service as a sole proprietorship. Jim’s Lawn Service obtained a fictitious name
registration, but never registered as a corporation. After working hard for other people for many
years, Jim had managed to buy his own home and had accumulated a nice little
savings account of around $50,000.00. having
tired of working for other people, he started his lawn care service.
He purchased lawn care equipment from a company that was going out
of business. Between his truck, trailer, and lawn equipment,
he had approximately $50,000 worth of assets in his business.
He obtained a loan from the bank to purchase these items.
After about a year, he had managed to pay down the loan so that he
had around $25,000 in equity in his business assets. Jim also loved toys. He
owned a jet ski, a camper, a ski boat and motor.
One day,
while water skiing, Jim took a very bad fall. He did severe damage to his neck and back and
suffered a severe concussion. Jim
was unable to work after the accident. His
business came to a screeching halt. He
tired to have employees take over much of the responsibility, but this lead
to more problems, customer complaints and headaches. After four months, Jim’s business was run into
the ground. He was 2 months late on
his payment to the bank for his business loan.
Jim
tried to explain to the bank. At first the bank was willing to try to work with him. But after four months of no payment had gone
by and there was no real indication of when Jim would be able to return to
the business, the bank called the loan, repossessed the equipment, had the
equipment sold at auction, and then began collection action against Jim on
the deficiency. At auction, Jim’s
equipment had only brought $10,000. The
bank obtained a judgment against Jim personally for the $40,000 deficiency.
There
was nothing that Jim could do about this. He had spent much of his $50,000 in savings
to support his household expenses during his period of recovery. He was down to around $20,000 in the bank.
And he needed this money to keep his house going in the foreseeable
future. He couldn’t afford to spend
that money to hire and attorney. And he felt that he couldn’t risk spending
that money to keep his business going. It
was time for Jim to realize that his business was finished.
Jim
felt that he had some time. He could keep his house and family going, if they pinched pennies,
for another six to eight months. In
the meantime, his wife would go back to work and hopefully by the end of that
time, he would be recovered to the extent that he could get a job somewhere.
So Jim convinced himself that everything would be alright.
But then
Jim received certified mail from the bank that they would be attaching his
bank account to satisfy the deficiency judgment. Around the same time, Jim received another
certified mail. He was being sued
by one of his employees. Apparently,
one of the persons that Jim had hired to take over his business while he was
recovering, had an accident and done some damage to his leg while on the job. He was now seeking compensation fro his injuries
from Jim.
So Jim
was now facing having his personal savings taken to satisfy the bank loan.
Additionally, the rest of his personal assets were vulnerable to the
employee lawsuit. And on top of this, Jim had trade creditors
that were breathing down his back for another $15,000.
Jim finally
went to see an attorney. The attorney advised him that he had no choice
at this point than to take a personal bankruptcy. This would stop all the collection efforts
against him. The downside was that
he would have to liquidate his personal assets.
Jim would
never had been in this situation if he had operated his business through a
corporation. The bank loan would have been in the name of the Corporation. The employee lawsuit would have been against
the Corporation and the Corporation’s assets; not against Jim individually. The trade creditors would have had claims against
the corporation; not against Jim individually. When Jim went to see the attorney, had he been
incorporated, the attorney’s answer would have been completely different.
Jim’s personal assets would not have been vulnerable and Jim would
not have had to face personal bankruptcy.
Jim learned
a very expensive lesson with this case. His friend had told him that it didn’t pay to incorporate unless
his business was making over $50,000 per year.
This is a common myth that is heard time after time. This is a myth. Regardless of the level of revenues of your business, you should
incorporate. This is because the potential
liabilities from operating your business are the relevant factor; not the
level of revenues achieved through your business. If you are not incorporated, all of these potential liabilities
present risk to your personal assets. Jim’s
life would be much different today if he would have incorporated his business.




|